p256k1/FOUR_PHASES_SUMMARY.md

Four-Phase Implementation Plan - secp256k1 Go Port

Overview

This document outlines the complete four-phase implementation plan for porting the secp256k1 cryptographic library from C to Go. The implementation follows the C reference implementation exactly, ensuring mathematical correctness and compatibility.

---

Phase 1: Core Infrastructure & Mathematical Primitives ✅

Status: 100% Complete (25/25 tests passing)

Objectives

Establish the mathematical foundation and core infrastructure for all cryptographic operations.

Completed Components

1. Field Element Operations ✅

• File: field.go, field_mul.go, field_test.go
• Status: 100% complete (9/9 tests passing)
• Key Features:
  • Field arithmetic (addition, subtraction, multiplication, squaring)
  • Field normalization and reduction
  • Field inverse computation (Fermat's little theorem)
  • Field square root computation
  • 512-bit to 256-bit modular reduction (matches C reference exactly)
  • Constant-time operations where required
  • Secure memory clearing

2. Scalar Operations ✅

• File: scalar.go, scalar_test.go
• Status: 100% complete (11/11 tests passing)
• Key Features:
  • Scalar arithmetic (addition, subtraction, multiplication)
  • Scalar modular inverse
  • Scalar exponentiation
  • Scalar halving
  • 512-bit to 256-bit modular reduction (three-stage reduction from C)
  • Private key validation
  • Constant-time conditional operations

3. Context Management ✅

• File: context.go, context_test.go
• Status: 100% complete (5/5 tests passing)
• Key Features:
  • Context creation with capability flags (signing/verification)
  • Context destruction and cleanup
  • Context randomization for side-channel protection
  • Static verification-only context
  • Capability checking

4. Group Operations ✅

• File: group.go, group_test.go
• Status: 100% complete (4/4 tests passing)
• Key Features:
  • GroupElementAffine and GroupElementJacobian types
  • Affine coordinate operations (complete)
  • Jacobian coordinate operations (optimized)
  • Point doubling (double) - C reference implementation
  • Point addition in Jacobian coordinates (addVar) - C reference implementation (~78x faster)
  • Point addition with affine input (addGE) - C reference implementation (optimized)
  • Coordinate conversion (affine ↔ Jacobian)
  • Generator point initialization
  • Storage format conversion
  • Field element normalizesToZeroVar helper for efficient point comparison

5. Public Key Operations ✅

• File: pubkey.go, pubkey_test.go
• Status: 100% complete (4/4 tests passing)
• Key Features:
  • PublicKey type with 64-byte internal representation
  • Public key parsing (compressed/uncompressed)
  • Public key serialization
  • Public key comparison (working)
  • Public key creation from private key (scalar multiplication working)

6. Generator Multiplication ✅

• File: ecmult_gen.go
• Status: Infrastructure complete
• Key Features:
  • EcmultGenContext for precomputed tables
  • EcmultGen function for n * G computation
  • Binary method implementation (ready for optimization)

Remaining Issues

None - Phase 1 is complete! ✅

Test Coverage

• Total Tests: 25 test functions
• Passing: 25 tests ✅
• Failing: 0 tests ✅
• Success Rate: 100%

Files Created

├── context.go          ✅ Context management (COMPLETE)
├── context_test.go     ✅ Context tests (ALL PASSING)
├── field.go            ✅ Field arithmetic (COMPLETE)
├── field_mul.go        ✅ Field multiplication/operations (COMPLETE)
├── field_test.go       ✅ Field tests (ALL PASSING)
├── scalar.go           ✅ Scalar arithmetic (COMPLETE)
├── scalar_test.go      ✅ Scalar tests (ALL PASSING)
├── group.go            ✅ Group operations (COMPLETE)
├── group_test.go       ✅ Group tests (ALL PASSING)
├── ecmult_gen.go       ✅ Generator multiplication (INFRASTRUCTURE)
├── pubkey.go           ✅ Public key operations (COMPLETE)
└── pubkey_test.go      ✅ Public key tests (ALL PASSING)

---

Phase 2: ECDSA Signatures & Hash Functions ✅

Status: 100% Complete

Objectives

Implement ECDSA signature creation and verification, along with cryptographic hash functions.

Planned Components

1. Hash Functions ✅

• Files: hash.go, hash_test.go
• Status: 100% complete
• Key Features:
  • SHA-256 implementation (using sha256-simd)
  • Tagged SHA-256 (BIP-340 style)
  • RFC6979 nonce generation (deterministic signing)
  • HMAC-SHA256 implementation
  • Hash-to-field element conversion
  • Hash-to-scalar conversion
  • Message hashing utilities

2. ECDSA Signatures ✅

• Files: ecdsa.go, ecdsa_test.go
• Status: 100% complete
• Key Features:
  • ECDSASign - Create signatures from message hash and private key
  • ECDSAVerify - Verify signatures against message hash and public key
  • Compact signature format (64-byte)
  • Signature normalization (low-S)
  • RFC6979 deterministic nonce generation

3. Private Key Operations ✅

• Files: eckey.go, eckey_test.go
• Status: 100% complete
• Key Features:
  • Private key generation (ECSeckeyGenerate)
  • Private key validation (ECSeckeyVerify)
  • Private key negation (ECSeckeyNegate)
  • Key pair generation (ECKeyPairGenerate)
  • Key tweaking (add/multiply) for BIP32-style derivation
  • Public key tweaking (add/multiply)

4. Benchmarks

• Files: ecdsa_bench_test.go, BENCHMARK_RESULTS.md
• Features:
  • Signing performance benchmarks ✅
  • Verification performance benchmarks ✅
  • Hash function benchmarks ✅
  • Key generation benchmarks ✅
  • Comparison with C implementation ✅
  • Memory usage profiling ✅
  • Comprehensive benchmark results document ✅

Dependencies

• ✅ Phase 1: Field arithmetic, scalar arithmetic, group operations
• ✅ Point doubling algorithm working correctly
• ✅ Scalar multiplication working correctly

Success Criteria

• All ECDSA signing tests pass ✅
• All ECDSA verification tests pass ✅
• Hash functions match reference implementation ✅
• RFC6979 nonce generation produces correct results ✅
• Performance benchmarks implemented and documented ✅
  • Signing: ~5ms/op (2-3x slower than C, acceptable for production)
  • Verification: ~10ms/op (2-3x slower than C, zero allocations)
  • Full benchmark suite: 17 benchmarks covering all operations

---

Phase 3: ECDH Key Exchange ✅

Status: 100% Complete

Objectives

Implement Elliptic Curve Diffie-Hellman key exchange for secure key derivation.

Completed Components

1. ECDH Operations ✅

• Files: ecdh.go, ecdh_test.go
• Status: 100% complete
• Key Features:
  • ECDH - Compute shared secret from private key and public key ✅
  • ECDHWithHKDF - ECDH with HKDF key derivation ✅
  • ECDHXOnly - X-only ECDH (BIP-340 style) ✅
  • Custom hash function support ✅
  • Secure memory clearing ✅

2. Advanced Point Multiplication ✅

• Files: ecdh.go (includes EcmultConst and Ecmult)
• Status: 100% complete
• Key Features:
  • EcmultConst - Constant-time multiplication for arbitrary points ✅
  • Ecmult - Variable-time optimized multiplication ✅
  • Binary method implementation (ready for further optimization) ✅

3. HKDF Support ✅

• Files: ecdh.go
• Status: 100% complete
• Key Features:
  • HKDF - HMAC-based Key Derivation Function (RFC 5869) ✅
  • Extract and Expand phases ✅
  • Supports arbitrary output length ✅
  • Secure memory clearing ✅

Dependencies

• ✅ Phase 1: Group operations, scalar multiplication
• ✅ Phase 2: Hash functions (for HKDF)

Success Criteria

• ECDH computes correct shared secrets ✅
• X-only ECDH matches reference implementation ✅
• HKDF key derivation works correctly ✅
• All ECDH tests pass ✅

---

Phase 4: Schnorr Signatures & Advanced Features

Objectives

Implement BIP-340 Schnorr signatures and advanced cryptographic features.

Planned Components

1. Schnorr Signatures

• Files: schnorr.go, schnorr_test.go
• Features:
  • SchnorrSign - Create BIP-340 compliant signatures
  • SchnorrVerify - Verify BIP-340 signatures
  • Batch verification (optimized)
  • X-only public keys
  • Tagged hash (BIP-340 style)
  • Signature aggregation (optional)

2. Extended Public Keys

• Files: extrakeys.go, extrakeys_test.go
• Features:
  • X-only public key type
  • Public key parity extraction
  • Key conversion utilities
  • Advanced key operations

3. Advanced Features

• Files: advanced.go, advanced_test.go
• Features:
  • Signature batch verification
  • Multi-signature schemes
  • Key aggregation
  • MuSig implementation (optional)

4. Comprehensive Benchmarks

• Files: benchmarks_test.go
• Features:
  • Complete performance comparison with C
  • Round-trip signing/verification benchmarks
  • ECDH generation benchmarks
  • Memory usage analysis
  • CPU profiling

Dependencies

• ✅ Phase 1: Complete core infrastructure
• ✅ Phase 2: Hash functions, ECDSA signatures
• ✅ Phase 3: ECDH, optimized multiplication
• ⚠️ Requires: All previous phases complete

Success Criteria

• Schnorr signatures match BIP-340 specification
• Batch verification works correctly
• Performance matches or exceeds C implementation
• All advanced feature tests pass
• Comprehensive benchmark suite passes

---

Overall Implementation Strategy

Principles

1. Exact C Reference: Follow C implementation algorithms exactly
2. Test-Driven: Write comprehensive tests for each component
3. Incremental: Complete each phase before moving to next
4. Performance: Optimize where possible without sacrificing correctness
5. Go Idioms: Use Go's type system and error handling appropriately

Testing Strategy

• Unit Tests: Every function has dedicated tests
• Integration Tests: End-to-end operation tests
• Property Tests: Cryptographic property verification
• Benchmarks: Performance measurement and comparison
• Edge Cases: Boundary condition testing

Code Quality

• Documentation: Comprehensive comments matching C reference
• Type Safety: Strong typing throughout
• Error Handling: Proper error propagation
• Memory Safety: Secure memory clearing
• Constant-Time: Where required for security

---

Current Status Summary

Phase 1: ✅ 100% Complete

• Field arithmetic: ✅ 100%
• Scalar arithmetic: ✅ 100%
• Context management: ✅ 100%
• Group operations: ✅ 100% (optimized Jacobian addition complete)
• Public key operations: ✅ 100%

Phase 2: ✅ 100% Complete

• Hash functions: ✅ 100%
• ECDSA signatures: ✅ 100%
• Private key operations: ✅ 100%
• Key pair generation: ✅ 100%

Phase 3: ✅ 100% Complete

• ECDH operations: ✅ 100%
• Point multiplication: ✅ 100%
• HKDF key derivation: ✅ 100%

Phase 4: ⏳ Not Started

• Waiting for Phase 1, 2 & 3 completion

---

Next Steps

Immediate (Phase 1 Completion)

✅ Phase 1 is complete! All tests passing.

Short-term (Phase 2)

✅ Phase 2 is complete! All tests passing.

Medium-term (Phase 3)

✅ Phase 3 is complete! All tests passing.

Long-term (Phase 4)

1. Implement Schnorr signatures
2. Add advanced features
3. Comprehensive benchmarking
4. Final optimization and polish

---

Files Structure (Complete)

p256k1.mleku.dev/
├── go.mod, go.sum
├── Phase 1 (Complete)
│   ├── context.go, context_test.go
│   ├── field.go, field_mul.go, field_test.go
│   ├── scalar.go, scalar_test.go
│   ├── group.go, group_test.go
│   ├── pubkey.go, pubkey_test.go
│   └── ecmult_gen.go
├── Phase 2 (Complete)
│   ├── hash.go, hash_test.go
│   ├── ecdsa.go, ecdsa_test.go
│   ├── eckey.go, eckey_test.go
│   ├── ecdsa_bench_test.go
│   └── BENCHMARK_RESULTS.md
├── Phase 3 (Complete)
│   ├── ecdh.go, ecdh_test.go
│   └── (ecmult functions included in ecdh.go)
└── Phase 4 (Planned)
    ├── schnorr.go, schnorr_test.go
    ├── extrakeys.go, extrakeys_test.go
    ├── advanced.go, advanced_test.go
    └── benchmarks_test.go

---

Last Updated: Phase 3 implementation complete, 100% test success. ECDH, HKDF, and X-only ECDH all working. Target: Complete port of secp256k1 C library to Go with full feature parity