mleku/next.orly.dev
1
0
Fork 1
Code Issues 2 Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

Add detailed benchmark results for multiple relays.

Browse Source 
- Included results for `relayer-basic`, `strfry`, and `nostr-rs-relay` relay benchmarks.
- Comprehensive performance metrics added for throughput, latency, query, and concurrent operations.
- Reports saved as plain text and AsciiDoc formats.
This commit is contained in:
mleku
2025-09-20 12:06:57 +01:00
parent 81a40c04e5
commit 90f21fbcd1
14 changed files with 2053 additions and 121 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

140
cmd/benchmark/reports/run_20250920_101521/aggregate_report.txt Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,140 @@
================================================================
NOSTR RELAY BENCHMARK AGGREGATE REPORT
================================================================
Generated: 2025-09-20T11:04:39+00:00
Benchmark Configuration:
Events per test: 10000
Concurrent workers: 8
Test duration: 60s
Relays tested: 6
================================================================
SUMMARY BY RELAY
================================================================
Relay: next-orly
----------------------------------------
Status: COMPLETED
Events/sec: 1035.42
Events/sec: 659.20
Events/sec: 1094.56
Success Rate: 100.0%
Success Rate: 100.0%
Success Rate: 100.0%
Avg Latency: 470.069µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 750.491µs
Avg Latency: 190.573µs
P95 Latency: 693.101µs
P95 Latency: 289.761µs
P95 Latency: 22.450848ms
Relay: khatru-sqlite
----------------------------------------
Status: COMPLETED
Events/sec: 1105.61
Events/sec: 624.87
Events/sec: 1070.10
Success Rate: 100.0%
Success Rate: 100.0%
Success Rate: 100.0%
Avg Latency: 458.035µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 702.193µs
Avg Latency: 193.997µs
P95 Latency: 660.608µs
P95 Latency: 302.666µs
P95 Latency: 23.653412ms
Relay: khatru-badger
----------------------------------------
Status: COMPLETED
Events/sec: 1040.11
Events/sec: 663.14
Events/sec: 1065.58
Success Rate: 100.0%
Success Rate: 100.0%
Success Rate: 100.0%
Avg Latency: 454.784µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 706.219µs
Avg Latency: 193.914µs
P95 Latency: 654.637µs
P95 Latency: 296.525µs
P95 Latency: 21.642655ms
Relay: relayer-basic
----------------------------------------
Status: COMPLETED
Events/sec: 1104.88
Events/sec: 642.17
Events/sec: 1079.27
Success Rate: 100.0%
Success Rate: 100.0%
Success Rate: 100.0%
Avg Latency: 433.89µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 653.813µs
Avg Latency: 186.306µs
P95 Latency: 617.868µs
P95 Latency: 279.192µs
P95 Latency: 21.247322ms
Relay: strfry
----------------------------------------
Status: COMPLETED
Events/sec: 1090.49
Events/sec: 652.03
Events/sec: 1098.57
Success Rate: 100.0%
Success Rate: 100.0%
Success Rate: 100.0%
Avg Latency: 448.058µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 729.464µs
Avg Latency: 189.06µs
P95 Latency: 667.141µs
P95 Latency: 290.433µs
P95 Latency: 20.822884ms
Relay: nostr-rs-relay
----------------------------------------
Status: COMPLETED
Events/sec: 1123.91
Events/sec: 647.62
Events/sec: 1033.64
Success Rate: 100.0%
Success Rate: 100.0%
Success Rate: 100.0%
Avg Latency: 416.753µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 638.318µs
Avg Latency: 185.217µs
P95 Latency: 597.338µs
P95 Latency: 273.191µs
P95 Latency: 22.416221ms
================================================================
DETAILED RESULTS
================================================================
Individual relay reports are available in:
- /reports/run_20250920_101521/khatru-badger_results.txt
- /reports/run_20250920_101521/khatru-sqlite_results.txt
- /reports/run_20250920_101521/next-orly_results.txt
- /reports/run_20250920_101521/nostr-rs-relay_results.txt
- /reports/run_20250920_101521/relayer-basic_results.txt
- /reports/run_20250920_101521/strfry_results.txt
================================================================
BENCHMARK COMPARISON TABLE
================================================================
Relay Status Peak Tput/s Avg Latency Success Rate
---- ------ ----------- ----------- ------------
next-orly OK 1035.42 470.069µs 100.0%
khatru-sqlite OK 1105.61 458.035µs 100.0%
khatru-badger OK 1040.11 454.784µs 100.0%
relayer-basic OK 1104.88 433.89µs 100.0%
strfry OK 1090.49 448.058µs 100.0%
nostr-rs-relay OK 1123.91 416.753µs 100.0%
================================================================
End of Report
================================================================

298
cmd/benchmark/reports/run_20250920_101521/khatru-badger_results.txt Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,298 @@
Starting Nostr Relay Benchmark
Data Directory: /tmp/benchmark_khatru-badger_8
Events: 10000, Workers: 8, Duration: 1m0s
1758364309339505ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_khatru-badger_8: All 0 tables opened in 0s
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/levels.go:161 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758364309340007ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_khatru-badger_8: Discard stats nextEmptySlot: 0
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/discard.go:55 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758364309340039ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_khatru-badger_8: Set nextTxnTs to 0
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:358 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758364309340327ℹ️(*types.Uint32)(0xc000147840)({
value: (uint32) 1
})
/build/pkg/database/migrations.go:65
1758364309340465ℹ️migrating to version 1... /build/pkg/database/migrations.go:79
=== Starting test round 1/2 ===
RunPeakThroughputTest..
=== Peak Throughput Test ===
Events saved: 10000/10000 (100.0%)
Duration: 9.614321551s
Events/sec: 1040.11
Avg latency: 454.784µs
P90 latency: 596.266µs
P95 latency: 654.637µs
P99 latency: 844.569µs
Bottom 10% Avg latency: 706.219µs
RunBurstPatternTest..
=== Burst Pattern Test ===
Burst completed: 1000 events in 136.444875ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 141.806497ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 168.991278ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 167.713425ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 162.89698ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 157.775164ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 166.476709ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 161.742632ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 162.138977ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 156.657194ms
Burst test completed: 10000 events in 15.07982611s
Events/sec: 663.14
RunMixedReadWriteTest..
=== Mixed Read/Write Test ===
Pre-populating database for read tests...
Mixed test completed: 5000 writes, 5000 reads in 44.903267299s
Combined ops/sec: 222.70
RunQueryTest..
=== Query Test ===
Pre-populating database with 10000 events for query tests...
Query test completed: 3166 queries in 1m0.104195004s
Queries/sec: 52.68
Avg query latency: 125.847553ms
P95 query latency: 148.109766ms
P99 query latency: 212.054697ms
RunConcurrentQueryStoreTest..
=== Concurrent Query/Store Test ===
Pre-populating database with 5000 events for concurrent query/store test...
Concurrent test completed: 11366 operations (1366 queries, 10000 writes) in 1m0.127232573s
Operations/sec: 189.03
Avg latency: 16.671438ms
Avg query latency: 134.993072ms
Avg write latency: 508.703µs
P95 latency: 133.755996ms
P99 latency: 152.790563ms
Pausing 10s before next round...
=== Test round completed ===
=== Starting test round 2/2 ===
RunPeakThroughputTest..
=== Peak Throughput Test ===
Events saved: 10000/10000 (100.0%)
Duration: 9.384548186s
Events/sec: 1065.58
Avg latency: 566.375µs
P90 latency: 738.377µs
P95 latency: 839.679µs
P99 latency: 1.131084ms
Bottom 10% Avg latency: 1.312791ms
RunBurstPatternTest..
=== Burst Pattern Test ===
Burst completed: 1000 events in 166.832259ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 175.061575ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 168.897493ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 167.584171ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 178.212526ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 202.208945ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 154.130024ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 168.817721ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 153.032223ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 154.799008ms
Burst test completed: 10000 events in 15.449161726s
Events/sec: 647.28
RunMixedReadWriteTest..
=== Mixed Read/Write Test ===
Pre-populating database for read tests...
Mixed test completed: 5000 writes, 4582 reads in 1m0.037041762s
Combined ops/sec: 159.60
RunQueryTest..
=== Query Test ===
Pre-populating database with 10000 events for query tests...
Query test completed: 959 queries in 1m0.42440735s
Queries/sec: 15.87
Avg query latency: 418.846875ms
P95 query latency: 473.089327ms
P99 query latency: 650.467474ms
RunConcurrentQueryStoreTest..
=== Concurrent Query/Store Test ===
Pre-populating database with 5000 events for concurrent query/store test...
Concurrent test completed: 10484 operations (484 queries, 10000 writes) in 1m0.283590079s
Operations/sec: 173.91
Avg latency: 17.921964ms
Avg query latency: 381.041592ms
Avg write latency: 346.974µs
P95 latency: 1.269749ms
P99 latency: 399.015222ms
=== Test round completed ===
================================================================================
BENCHMARK REPORT
================================================================================
Test: Peak Throughput
Duration: 9.614321551s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 1040.11
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 118 MB
Avg Latency: 454.784µs
P90 Latency: 596.266µs
P95 Latency: 654.637µs
P99 Latency: 844.569µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 706.219µs
----------------------------------------
Test: Burst Pattern
Duration: 15.07982611s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 663.14
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 162 MB
Avg Latency: 193.914µs
P90 Latency: 255.617µs
P95 Latency: 296.525µs
P99 Latency: 451.81µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 343.222µs
----------------------------------------
Test: Mixed Read/Write
Duration: 44.903267299s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 222.70
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 121 MB
Avg Latency: 9.145633ms
P90 Latency: 19.946513ms
P95 Latency: 21.642655ms
P99 Latency: 23.951572ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 21.861602ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Query Performance
Duration: 1m0.104195004s
Total Events: 3166
Events/sec: 52.68
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 188 MB
Avg Latency: 125.847553ms
P90 Latency: 140.664966ms
P95 Latency: 148.109766ms
P99 Latency: 212.054697ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 164.089129ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Concurrent Query/Store
Duration: 1m0.127232573s
Total Events: 11366
Events/sec: 189.03
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 112 MB
Avg Latency: 16.671438ms
P90 Latency: 122.627849ms
P95 Latency: 133.755996ms
P99 Latency: 152.790563ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 138.087104ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Peak Throughput
Duration: 9.384548186s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 1065.58
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 1441 MB
Avg Latency: 566.375µs
P90 Latency: 738.377µs
P95 Latency: 839.679µs
P99 Latency: 1.131084ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 1.312791ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Burst Pattern
Duration: 15.449161726s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 647.28
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 165 MB
Avg Latency: 186.353µs
P90 Latency: 243.413µs
P95 Latency: 283.06µs
P99 Latency: 440.76µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 324.151µs
----------------------------------------
Test: Mixed Read/Write
Duration: 1m0.037041762s
Total Events: 9582
Events/sec: 159.60
Success Rate: 95.8%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 138 MB
Avg Latency: 16.358228ms
P90 Latency: 37.654373ms
P95 Latency: 40.578604ms
P99 Latency: 46.331181ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 41.76124ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Query Performance
Duration: 1m0.42440735s
Total Events: 959
Events/sec: 15.87
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 110 MB
Avg Latency: 418.846875ms
P90 Latency: 448.809017ms
P95 Latency: 473.089327ms
P99 Latency: 650.467474ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 518.112626ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Concurrent Query/Store
Duration: 1m0.283590079s
Total Events: 10484
Events/sec: 173.91
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 205 MB
Avg Latency: 17.921964ms
P90 Latency: 582.319µs
P95 Latency: 1.269749ms
P99 Latency: 399.015222ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 176.257001ms
----------------------------------------
Report saved to: /tmp/benchmark_khatru-badger_8/benchmark_report.txt
AsciiDoc report saved to: /tmp/benchmark_khatru-badger_8/benchmark_report.adoc
1758364794792663ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_khatru-badger_8: Lifetime L0 stalled for: 0s
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:536 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758364796617126ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_khatru-badger_8:
Level 0 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 0 B. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 64 MiB
Level 1 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 2 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 3 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 4 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 5 [B]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 6 [ ]: NumTables: 04. Size: 87 MiB of 87 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 4.0 MiB
Level Done
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:615 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758364796621659ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_khatru-badger_8: database closed /build/pkg/database/database.go:134
RELAY_NAME: khatru-badger
RELAY_URL: ws://khatru-badger:3334
TEST_TIMESTAMP: 2025-09-20T10:39:56+00:00
BENCHMARK_CONFIG:
Events: 10000
Workers: 8
Duration: 60s

298
cmd/benchmark/reports/run_20250920_101521/khatru-sqlite_results.txt Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,298 @@
Starting Nostr Relay Benchmark
Data Directory: /tmp/benchmark_khatru-sqlite_8
Events: 10000, Workers: 8, Duration: 1m0s
1758363814412229ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_khatru-sqlite_8: All 0 tables opened in 0s
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/levels.go:161 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758363814412803ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_khatru-sqlite_8: Discard stats nextEmptySlot: 0
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/discard.go:55 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758363814412840ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_khatru-sqlite_8: Set nextTxnTs to 0
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:358 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758363814413123ℹ️(*types.Uint32)(0xc0001ea00c)({
value: (uint32) 1
})
/build/pkg/database/migrations.go:65
1758363814413200ℹ️migrating to version 1... /build/pkg/database/migrations.go:79
=== Starting test round 1/2 ===
RunPeakThroughputTest..
=== Peak Throughput Test ===
Events saved: 10000/10000 (100.0%)
Duration: 9.044789549s
Events/sec: 1105.61
Avg latency: 458.035µs
P90 latency: 601.736µs
P95 latency: 660.608µs
P99 latency: 844.108µs
Bottom 10% Avg latency: 702.193µs
RunBurstPatternTest..
=== Burst Pattern Test ===
Burst completed: 1000 events in 146.610877ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 179.229665ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 157.096919ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 164.796374ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 188.464354ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 196.529596ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 169.425581ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 147.99354ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 157.996252ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 167.299262ms
Burst test completed: 10000 events in 16.003207139s
Events/sec: 624.87
RunMixedReadWriteTest..
=== Mixed Read/Write Test ===
Pre-populating database for read tests...
Mixed test completed: 5000 writes, 5000 reads in 46.924555793s
Combined ops/sec: 213.11
RunQueryTest..
=== Query Test ===
Pre-populating database with 10000 events for query tests...
Query test completed: 3052 queries in 1m0.102264s
Queries/sec: 50.78
Avg query latency: 128.464192ms
P95 query latency: 148.086431ms
P99 query latency: 219.275394ms
RunConcurrentQueryStoreTest..
=== Concurrent Query/Store Test ===
Pre-populating database with 5000 events for concurrent query/store test...
Concurrent test completed: 11296 operations (1296 queries, 10000 writes) in 1m0.108871986s
Operations/sec: 187.93
Avg latency: 16.71621ms
Avg query latency: 142.320434ms
Avg write latency: 437.903µs
P95 latency: 141.357185ms
P99 latency: 163.50992ms
Pausing 10s before next round...
=== Test round completed ===
=== Starting test round 2/2 ===
RunPeakThroughputTest..
=== Peak Throughput Test ===
Events saved: 10000/10000 (100.0%)
Duration: 9.344884331s
Events/sec: 1070.10
Avg latency: 578.453µs
P90 latency: 742.585µs
P95 latency: 849.679µs
P99 latency: 1.122058ms
Bottom 10% Avg latency: 1.362355ms
RunBurstPatternTest..
=== Burst Pattern Test ===
Burst completed: 1000 events in 185.472655ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 194.135516ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 176.056931ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 161.500315ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 157.673837ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 167.130208ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 182.164655ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 156.589581ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 154.419949ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 158.445927ms
Burst test completed: 10000 events in 15.587711126s
Events/sec: 641.53
RunMixedReadWriteTest..
=== Mixed Read/Write Test ===
Pre-populating database for read tests...
Mixed test completed: 5000 writes, 4405 reads in 1m0.043842569s
Combined ops/sec: 156.64
RunQueryTest..
=== Query Test ===
Pre-populating database with 10000 events for query tests...
Query test completed: 915 queries in 1m0.3452177s
Queries/sec: 15.16
Avg query latency: 435.125142ms
P95 query latency: 520.311963ms
P99 query latency: 618.85899ms
RunConcurrentQueryStoreTest..
=== Concurrent Query/Store Test ===
Pre-populating database with 5000 events for concurrent query/store test...
Concurrent test completed: 10489 operations (489 queries, 10000 writes) in 1m0.27235761s
Operations/sec: 174.03
Avg latency: 18.043774ms
Avg query latency: 379.681531ms
Avg write latency: 359.688µs
P95 latency: 1.316628ms
P99 latency: 400.223248ms
=== Test round completed ===
================================================================================
BENCHMARK REPORT
================================================================================
Test: Peak Throughput
Duration: 9.044789549s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 1105.61
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 144 MB
Avg Latency: 458.035µs
P90 Latency: 601.736µs
P95 Latency: 660.608µs
P99 Latency: 844.108µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 702.193µs
----------------------------------------
Test: Burst Pattern
Duration: 16.003207139s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 624.87
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 89 MB
Avg Latency: 193.997µs
P90 Latency: 261.969µs
P95 Latency: 302.666µs
P99 Latency: 431.933µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 334.383µs
----------------------------------------
Test: Mixed Read/Write
Duration: 46.924555793s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 213.11
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 96 MB
Avg Latency: 9.781737ms
P90 Latency: 21.91971ms
P95 Latency: 23.653412ms
P99 Latency: 27.511972ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 24.396695ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Query Performance
Duration: 1m0.102264s
Total Events: 3052
Events/sec: 50.78
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 209 MB
Avg Latency: 128.464192ms
P90 Latency: 142.195039ms
P95 Latency: 148.086431ms
P99 Latency: 219.275394ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 162.874217ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Concurrent Query/Store
Duration: 1m0.108871986s
Total Events: 11296
Events/sec: 187.93
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 159 MB
Avg Latency: 16.71621ms
P90 Latency: 127.287246ms
P95 Latency: 141.357185ms
P99 Latency: 163.50992ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 145.199189ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Peak Throughput
Duration: 9.344884331s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 1070.10
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 1441 MB
Avg Latency: 578.453µs
P90 Latency: 742.585µs
P95 Latency: 849.679µs
P99 Latency: 1.122058ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 1.362355ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Burst Pattern
Duration: 15.587711126s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 641.53
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 141 MB
Avg Latency: 190.235µs
P90 Latency: 254.795µs
P95 Latency: 290.563µs
P99 Latency: 437.323µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 328.752µs
----------------------------------------
Test: Mixed Read/Write
Duration: 1m0.043842569s
Total Events: 9405
Events/sec: 156.64
Success Rate: 94.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 105 MB
Avg Latency: 16.852438ms
P90 Latency: 39.677855ms
P95 Latency: 42.553634ms
P99 Latency: 48.262077ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 43.994063ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Query Performance
Duration: 1m0.3452177s
Total Events: 915
Events/sec: 15.16
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 157 MB
Avg Latency: 435.125142ms
P90 Latency: 482.304439ms
P95 Latency: 520.311963ms
P99 Latency: 618.85899ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 545.670939ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Concurrent Query/Store
Duration: 1m0.27235761s
Total Events: 10489
Events/sec: 174.03
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 132 MB
Avg Latency: 18.043774ms
P90 Latency: 583.962µs
P95 Latency: 1.316628ms
P99 Latency: 400.223248ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 177.440946ms
----------------------------------------
Report saved to: /tmp/benchmark_khatru-sqlite_8/benchmark_report.txt
AsciiDoc report saved to: /tmp/benchmark_khatru-sqlite_8/benchmark_report.adoc
1758364302230610ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_khatru-sqlite_8: Lifetime L0 stalled for: 0s
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:536 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758364304057942ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_khatru-sqlite_8:
Level 0 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 0 B. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 64 MiB
Level 1 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 2 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 3 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 4 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 5 [B]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 6 [ ]: NumTables: 04. Size: 87 MiB of 87 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 4.0 MiB
Level Done
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:615 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758364304063521ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_khatru-sqlite_8: database closed /build/pkg/database/database.go:134
RELAY_NAME: khatru-sqlite
RELAY_URL: ws://khatru-sqlite:3334
TEST_TIMESTAMP: 2025-09-20T10:31:44+00:00
BENCHMARK_CONFIG:
Events: 10000
Workers: 8
Duration: 60s

298
cmd/benchmark/reports/run_20250920_101521/next-orly_results.txt Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,298 @@
Starting Nostr Relay Benchmark
Data Directory: /tmp/benchmark_next-orly_8
Events: 10000, Workers: 8, Duration: 1m0s
1758363321263384ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_next-orly_8: All 0 tables opened in 0s
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/levels.go:161 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758363321263864ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_next-orly_8: Discard stats nextEmptySlot: 0
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/discard.go:55 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758363321263887ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_next-orly_8: Set nextTxnTs to 0
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:358 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758363321264128ℹ️(*types.Uint32)(0xc0001f7ffc)({
value: (uint32) 1
})
/build/pkg/database/migrations.go:65
1758363321264177ℹ️migrating to version 1... /build/pkg/database/migrations.go:79
=== Starting test round 1/2 ===
RunPeakThroughputTest..
=== Peak Throughput Test ===
Events saved: 10000/10000 (100.0%)
Duration: 9.657904043s
Events/sec: 1035.42
Avg latency: 470.069µs
P90 latency: 628.167µs
P95 latency: 693.101µs
P99 latency: 922.357µs
Bottom 10% Avg latency: 750.491µs
RunBurstPatternTest..
=== Burst Pattern Test ===
Burst completed: 1000 events in 175.034134ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 150.401771ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 168.992305ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 179.447581ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 165.602457ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 178.649561ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 195.002303ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 168.970954ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 150.818413ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 185.285662ms
Burst test completed: 10000 events in 15.169978801s
Events/sec: 659.20
RunMixedReadWriteTest..
=== Mixed Read/Write Test ===
Pre-populating database for read tests...
Mixed test completed: 5000 writes, 5000 reads in 45.597478865s
Combined ops/sec: 219.31
RunQueryTest..
=== Query Test ===
Pre-populating database with 10000 events for query tests...
Query test completed: 3151 queries in 1m0.067849757s
Queries/sec: 52.46
Avg query latency: 126.38548ms
P95 query latency: 149.976367ms
P99 query latency: 205.807461ms
RunConcurrentQueryStoreTest..
=== Concurrent Query/Store Test ===
Pre-populating database with 5000 events for concurrent query/store test...
Concurrent test completed: 11325 operations (1325 queries, 10000 writes) in 1m0.081967157s
Operations/sec: 188.49
Avg latency: 16.694154ms
Avg query latency: 139.524748ms
Avg write latency: 419.1µs
P95 latency: 138.688202ms
P99 latency: 158.824742ms
Pausing 10s before next round...
=== Test round completed ===
=== Starting test round 2/2 ===
RunPeakThroughputTest..
=== Peak Throughput Test ===
Events saved: 10000/10000 (100.0%)
Duration: 9.136097148s
Events/sec: 1094.56
Avg latency: 510.7µs
P90 latency: 636.763µs
P95 latency: 705.564µs
P99 latency: 922.777µs
Bottom 10% Avg latency: 1.094965ms
RunBurstPatternTest..
=== Burst Pattern Test ===
Burst completed: 1000 events in 176.337148ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 177.351251ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 181.515292ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 164.043866ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 152.697196ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 144.231922ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 162.606659ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 137.485182ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 163.19487ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 147.900339ms
Burst test completed: 10000 events in 15.514130113s
Events/sec: 644.57
RunMixedReadWriteTest..
=== Mixed Read/Write Test ===
Pre-populating database for read tests...
Mixed test completed: 5000 writes, 4489 reads in 1m0.036174989s
Combined ops/sec: 158.05
RunQueryTest..
=== Query Test ===
Pre-populating database with 10000 events for query tests...
Query test completed: 900 queries in 1m0.304636826s
Queries/sec: 14.92
Avg query latency: 444.57989ms
P95 query latency: 547.598358ms
P99 query latency: 660.926147ms
RunConcurrentQueryStoreTest..
=== Concurrent Query/Store Test ===
Pre-populating database with 5000 events for concurrent query/store test...
Concurrent test completed: 10462 operations (462 queries, 10000 writes) in 1m0.362856212s
Operations/sec: 173.32
Avg latency: 17.808607ms
Avg query latency: 395.594177ms
Avg write latency: 354.914µs
P95 latency: 1.221657ms
P99 latency: 411.642669ms
=== Test round completed ===
================================================================================
BENCHMARK REPORT
================================================================================
Test: Peak Throughput
Duration: 9.657904043s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 1035.42
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 144 MB
Avg Latency: 470.069µs
P90 Latency: 628.167µs
P95 Latency: 693.101µs
P99 Latency: 922.357µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 750.491µs
----------------------------------------
Test: Burst Pattern
Duration: 15.169978801s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 659.20
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 135 MB
Avg Latency: 190.573µs
P90 Latency: 252.701µs
P95 Latency: 289.761µs
P99 Latency: 408.147µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 316.797µs
----------------------------------------
Test: Mixed Read/Write
Duration: 45.597478865s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 219.31
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 119 MB
Avg Latency: 9.381158ms
P90 Latency: 20.487026ms
P95 Latency: 22.450848ms
P99 Latency: 24.696325ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 22.632933ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Query Performance
Duration: 1m0.067849757s
Total Events: 3151
Events/sec: 52.46
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 145 MB
Avg Latency: 126.38548ms
P90 Latency: 142.39268ms
P95 Latency: 149.976367ms
P99 Latency: 205.807461ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 162.636454ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Concurrent Query/Store
Duration: 1m0.081967157s
Total Events: 11325
Events/sec: 188.49
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 194 MB
Avg Latency: 16.694154ms
P90 Latency: 125.314618ms
P95 Latency: 138.688202ms
P99 Latency: 158.824742ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 142.699977ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Peak Throughput
Duration: 9.136097148s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 1094.56
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 1441 MB
Avg Latency: 510.7µs
P90 Latency: 636.763µs
P95 Latency: 705.564µs
P99 Latency: 922.777µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 1.094965ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Burst Pattern
Duration: 15.514130113s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 644.57
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 138 MB
Avg Latency: 230.062µs
P90 Latency: 316.624µs
P95 Latency: 389.882µs
P99 Latency: 859.548µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 529.836µs
----------------------------------------
Test: Mixed Read/Write
Duration: 1m0.036174989s
Total Events: 9489
Events/sec: 158.05
Success Rate: 94.9%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 182 MB
Avg Latency: 16.56372ms
P90 Latency: 38.24931ms
P95 Latency: 41.187306ms
P99 Latency: 46.02529ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 42.131189ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Query Performance
Duration: 1m0.304636826s
Total Events: 900
Events/sec: 14.92
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 141 MB
Avg Latency: 444.57989ms
P90 Latency: 490.730651ms
P95 Latency: 547.598358ms
P99 Latency: 660.926147ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 563.628707ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Concurrent Query/Store
Duration: 1m0.362856212s
Total Events: 10462
Events/sec: 173.32
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 152 MB
Avg Latency: 17.808607ms
P90 Latency: 631.703µs
P95 Latency: 1.221657ms
P99 Latency: 411.642669ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 175.052418ms
----------------------------------------
Report saved to: /tmp/benchmark_next-orly_8/benchmark_report.txt
AsciiDoc report saved to: /tmp/benchmark_next-orly_8/benchmark_report.adoc
1758363807245770ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_next-orly_8: Lifetime L0 stalled for: 0s
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:536 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758363809118416ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_next-orly_8:
Level 0 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 0 B. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 64 MiB
Level 1 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 2 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 3 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 4 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 5 [B]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 6 [ ]: NumTables: 04. Size: 87 MiB of 87 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 4.0 MiB
Level Done
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:615 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758363809123697ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_next-orly_8: database closed /build/pkg/database/database.go:134
RELAY_NAME: next-orly
RELAY_URL: ws://next-orly:8080
TEST_TIMESTAMP: 2025-09-20T10:23:29+00:00
BENCHMARK_CONFIG:
Events: 10000
Workers: 8
Duration: 60s

298
cmd/benchmark/reports/run_20250920_101521/nostr-rs-relay_results.txt Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,298 @@
Starting Nostr Relay Benchmark
Data Directory: /tmp/benchmark_nostr-rs-relay_8
Events: 10000, Workers: 8, Duration: 1m0s
1758365785928076ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_nostr-rs-relay_8: All 0 tables opened in 0s
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/levels.go:161 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758365785929028ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_nostr-rs-relay_8: Discard stats nextEmptySlot: 0
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/discard.go:55 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758365785929097ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_nostr-rs-relay_8: Set nextTxnTs to 0
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:358 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758365785929509ℹ️(*types.Uint32)(0xc0001c820c)({
value: (uint32) 1
})
/build/pkg/database/migrations.go:65
1758365785929573ℹ️migrating to version 1... /build/pkg/database/migrations.go:79
=== Starting test round 1/2 ===
RunPeakThroughputTest..
=== Peak Throughput Test ===
Events saved: 10000/10000 (100.0%)
Duration: 8.897492256s
Events/sec: 1123.91
Avg latency: 416.753µs
P90 latency: 546.351µs
P95 latency: 597.338µs
P99 latency: 760.549µs
Bottom 10% Avg latency: 638.318µs
RunBurstPatternTest..
=== Burst Pattern Test ===
Burst completed: 1000 events in 158.263016ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 181.558983ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 155.219861ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 183.834156ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 192.398437ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 176.450074ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 175.050138ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 178.883047ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 180.74321ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 169.39146ms
Burst test completed: 10000 events in 15.441062872s
Events/sec: 647.62
RunMixedReadWriteTest..
=== Mixed Read/Write Test ===
Pre-populating database for read tests...
Mixed test completed: 5000 writes, 5000 reads in 45.847091984s
Combined ops/sec: 218.12
RunQueryTest..
=== Query Test ===
Pre-populating database with 10000 events for query tests...
Query test completed: 3229 queries in 1m0.085047549s
Queries/sec: 53.74
Avg query latency: 123.209617ms
P95 query latency: 141.745618ms
P99 query latency: 154.527843ms
RunConcurrentQueryStoreTest..
=== Concurrent Query/Store Test ===
Pre-populating database with 5000 events for concurrent query/store test...
Concurrent test completed: 11298 operations (1298 queries, 10000 writes) in 1m0.096751583s
Operations/sec: 188.00
Avg latency: 16.447175ms
Avg query latency: 139.791065ms
Avg write latency: 437.138µs
P95 latency: 137.879538ms
P99 latency: 162.020385ms
Pausing 10s before next round...
=== Test round completed ===
=== Starting test round 2/2 ===
RunPeakThroughputTest..
=== Peak Throughput Test ===
Events saved: 10000/10000 (100.0%)
Duration: 9.674593819s
Events/sec: 1033.64
Avg latency: 541.545µs
P90 latency: 693.862µs
P95 latency: 775.757µs
P99 latency: 1.05005ms
Bottom 10% Avg latency: 1.219386ms
RunBurstPatternTest..
=== Burst Pattern Test ===
Burst completed: 1000 events in 168.056064ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 159.819647ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 147.500264ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 159.150392ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 149.954829ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 138.082938ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 157.234213ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 158.468955ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 144.346047ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 154.930576ms
Burst test completed: 10000 events in 15.646785427s
Events/sec: 639.11
RunMixedReadWriteTest..
=== Mixed Read/Write Test ===
Pre-populating database for read tests...
Mixed test completed: 5000 writes, 4415 reads in 1m0.02899167s
Combined ops/sec: 156.84
RunQueryTest..
=== Query Test ===
Pre-populating database with 10000 events for query tests...
Query test completed: 890 queries in 1m0.279192867s
Queries/sec: 14.76
Avg query latency: 448.809547ms
P95 query latency: 607.28509ms
P99 query latency: 786.387053ms
RunConcurrentQueryStoreTest..
=== Concurrent Query/Store Test ===
Pre-populating database with 5000 events for concurrent query/store test...
Concurrent test completed: 10469 operations (469 queries, 10000 writes) in 1m0.190785048s
Operations/sec: 173.93
Avg latency: 17.73903ms
Avg query latency: 388.59336ms
Avg write latency: 345.962µs
P95 latency: 1.158136ms
P99 latency: 407.947907ms
=== Test round completed ===
================================================================================
BENCHMARK REPORT
================================================================================
Test: Peak Throughput
Duration: 8.897492256s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 1123.91
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 132 MB
Avg Latency: 416.753µs
P90 Latency: 546.351µs
P95 Latency: 597.338µs
P99 Latency: 760.549µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 638.318µs
----------------------------------------
Test: Burst Pattern
Duration: 15.441062872s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 647.62
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 104 MB
Avg Latency: 185.217µs
P90 Latency: 241.64µs
P95 Latency: 273.191µs
P99 Latency: 412.897µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 306.752µs
----------------------------------------
Test: Mixed Read/Write
Duration: 45.847091984s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 218.12
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 96 MB
Avg Latency: 9.446215ms
P90 Latency: 20.522135ms
P95 Latency: 22.416221ms
P99 Latency: 24.696283ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 22.59535ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Query Performance
Duration: 1m0.085047549s
Total Events: 3229
Events/sec: 53.74
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 175 MB
Avg Latency: 123.209617ms
P90 Latency: 137.629898ms
P95 Latency: 141.745618ms
P99 Latency: 154.527843ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 145.245967ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Concurrent Query/Store
Duration: 1m0.096751583s
Total Events: 11298
Events/sec: 188.00
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 181 MB
Avg Latency: 16.447175ms
P90 Latency: 123.920421ms
P95 Latency: 137.879538ms
P99 Latency: 162.020385ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 142.654147ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Peak Throughput
Duration: 9.674593819s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 1033.64
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 1441 MB
Avg Latency: 541.545µs
P90 Latency: 693.862µs
P95 Latency: 775.757µs
P99 Latency: 1.05005ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 1.219386ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Burst Pattern
Duration: 15.646785427s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 639.11
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 146 MB
Avg Latency: 331.896µs
P90 Latency: 520.511µs
P95 Latency: 864.486µs
P99 Latency: 2.251087ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 1.16922ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Mixed Read/Write
Duration: 1m0.02899167s
Total Events: 9415
Events/sec: 156.84
Success Rate: 94.2%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 147 MB
Avg Latency: 16.723365ms
P90 Latency: 39.058801ms
P95 Latency: 41.904891ms
P99 Latency: 47.156263ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 42.800456ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Query Performance
Duration: 1m0.279192867s
Total Events: 890
Events/sec: 14.76
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 156 MB
Avg Latency: 448.809547ms
P90 Latency: 524.488485ms
P95 Latency: 607.28509ms
P99 Latency: 786.387053ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 634.016595ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Concurrent Query/Store
Duration: 1m0.190785048s
Total Events: 10469
Events/sec: 173.93
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 226 MB
Avg Latency: 17.73903ms
P90 Latency: 561.359µs
P95 Latency: 1.158136ms
P99 Latency: 407.947907ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 174.508065ms
----------------------------------------
Report saved to: /tmp/benchmark_nostr-rs-relay_8/benchmark_report.txt
AsciiDoc report saved to: /tmp/benchmark_nostr-rs-relay_8/benchmark_report.adoc
1758366272164052ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_nostr-rs-relay_8: Lifetime L0 stalled for: 0s
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:536 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758366274030399ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_nostr-rs-relay_8:
Level 0 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 0 B. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 64 MiB
Level 1 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 2 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 3 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 4 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 5 [B]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 6 [ ]: NumTables: 04. Size: 87 MiB of 87 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 4.0 MiB
Level Done
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:615 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758366274036413ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_nostr-rs-relay_8: database closed /build/pkg/database/database.go:134
RELAY_NAME: nostr-rs-relay
RELAY_URL: ws://nostr-rs-relay:8080
TEST_TIMESTAMP: 2025-09-20T11:04:34+00:00
BENCHMARK_CONFIG:
Events: 10000
Workers: 8
Duration: 60s

298
cmd/benchmark/reports/run_20250920_101521/relayer-basic_results.txt Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,298 @@
Starting Nostr Relay Benchmark
Data Directory: /tmp/benchmark_relayer-basic_8
Events: 10000, Workers: 8, Duration: 1m0s
1758364801895559ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_relayer-basic_8: All 0 tables opened in 0s
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/levels.go:161 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758364801896041ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_relayer-basic_8: Discard stats nextEmptySlot: 0
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/discard.go:55 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758364801896078ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_relayer-basic_8: Set nextTxnTs to 0
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:358 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758364801896347ℹ️(*types.Uint32)(0xc0001a801c)({
value: (uint32) 1
})
/build/pkg/database/migrations.go:65
1758364801896400ℹ️migrating to version 1... /build/pkg/database/migrations.go:79
=== Starting test round 1/2 ===
RunPeakThroughputTest..
=== Peak Throughput Test ===
Events saved: 10000/10000 (100.0%)
Duration: 9.050770003s
Events/sec: 1104.88
Avg latency: 433.89µs
P90 latency: 567.261µs
P95 latency: 617.868µs
P99 latency: 783.593µs
Bottom 10% Avg latency: 653.813µs
RunBurstPatternTest..
=== Burst Pattern Test ===
Burst completed: 1000 events in 183.738134ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 155.035832ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 160.066514ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 183.724238ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 178.910929ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 168.905441ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 172.584809ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 177.214508ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 169.921566ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 162.042488ms
Burst test completed: 10000 events in 15.572250139s
Events/sec: 642.17
RunMixedReadWriteTest..
=== Mixed Read/Write Test ===
Pre-populating database for read tests...
Mixed test completed: 5000 writes, 5000 reads in 44.509677166s
Combined ops/sec: 224.67
RunQueryTest..
=== Query Test ===
Pre-populating database with 10000 events for query tests...
Query test completed: 3253 queries in 1m0.095238426s
Queries/sec: 54.13
Avg query latency: 122.100718ms
P95 query latency: 140.360749ms
P99 query latency: 148.353154ms
RunConcurrentQueryStoreTest..
=== Concurrent Query/Store Test ===
Pre-populating database with 5000 events for concurrent query/store test...
Concurrent test completed: 11408 operations (1408 queries, 10000 writes) in 1m0.117581615s
Operations/sec: 189.76
Avg latency: 16.525268ms
Avg query latency: 130.972853ms
Avg write latency: 411.048µs
P95 latency: 132.130964ms
P99 latency: 146.285305ms
Pausing 10s before next round...
=== Test round completed ===
=== Starting test round 2/2 ===
RunPeakThroughputTest..
=== Peak Throughput Test ===
Events saved: 10000/10000 (100.0%)
Duration: 9.265496879s
Events/sec: 1079.27
Avg latency: 529.266µs
P90 latency: 658.033µs
P95 latency: 732.024µs
P99 latency: 953.285µs
Bottom 10% Avg latency: 1.168714ms
RunBurstPatternTest..
=== Burst Pattern Test ===
Burst completed: 1000 events in 172.300479ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 149.247397ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 170.000198ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 133.786958ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 172.157036ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 153.284738ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 166.711903ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 170.635427ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 153.381031ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 162.125949ms
Burst test completed: 10000 events in 16.674963543s
Events/sec: 599.70
RunMixedReadWriteTest..
=== Mixed Read/Write Test ===
Pre-populating database for read tests...
Mixed test completed: 5000 writes, 4665 reads in 1m0.035358264s
Combined ops/sec: 160.99
RunQueryTest..
=== Query Test ===
Pre-populating database with 10000 events for query tests...
Query test completed: 944 queries in 1m0.383519958s
Queries/sec: 15.63
Avg query latency: 421.75292ms
P95 query latency: 491.340259ms
P99 query latency: 664.614262ms
RunConcurrentQueryStoreTest..
=== Concurrent Query/Store Test ===
Pre-populating database with 5000 events for concurrent query/store test...
Concurrent test completed: 10479 operations (479 queries, 10000 writes) in 1m0.291926697s
Operations/sec: 173.80
Avg latency: 18.049265ms
Avg query latency: 385.864458ms
Avg write latency: 430.918µs
P95 latency: 3.05038ms
P99 latency: 404.540502ms
=== Test round completed ===
================================================================================
BENCHMARK REPORT
================================================================================
Test: Peak Throughput
Duration: 9.050770003s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 1104.88
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 153 MB
Avg Latency: 433.89µs
P90 Latency: 567.261µs
P95 Latency: 617.868µs
P99 Latency: 783.593µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 653.813µs
----------------------------------------
Test: Burst Pattern
Duration: 15.572250139s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 642.17
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 134 MB
Avg Latency: 186.306µs
P90 Latency: 243.995µs
P95 Latency: 279.192µs
P99 Latency: 392.859µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 303.766µs
----------------------------------------
Test: Mixed Read/Write
Duration: 44.509677166s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 224.67
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 163 MB
Avg Latency: 8.892738ms
P90 Latency: 19.406836ms
P95 Latency: 21.247322ms
P99 Latency: 23.452072ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 21.397913ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Query Performance
Duration: 1m0.095238426s
Total Events: 3253
Events/sec: 54.13
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 126 MB
Avg Latency: 122.100718ms
P90 Latency: 136.523661ms
P95 Latency: 140.360749ms
P99 Latency: 148.353154ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 142.067372ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Concurrent Query/Store
Duration: 1m0.117581615s
Total Events: 11408
Events/sec: 189.76
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 149 MB
Avg Latency: 16.525268ms
P90 Latency: 121.696848ms
P95 Latency: 132.130964ms
P99 Latency: 146.285305ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 134.054744ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Peak Throughput
Duration: 9.265496879s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 1079.27
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 1441 MB
Avg Latency: 529.266µs
P90 Latency: 658.033µs
P95 Latency: 732.024µs
P99 Latency: 953.285µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 1.168714ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Burst Pattern
Duration: 16.674963543s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 599.70
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 142 MB
Avg Latency: 264.288µs
P90 Latency: 350.187µs
P95 Latency: 519.139µs
P99 Latency: 1.961326ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 877.366µs
----------------------------------------
Test: Mixed Read/Write
Duration: 1m0.035358264s
Total Events: 9665
Events/sec: 160.99
Success Rate: 96.7%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 151 MB
Avg Latency: 16.019245ms
P90 Latency: 36.340362ms
P95 Latency: 39.113864ms
P99 Latency: 44.271098ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 40.108462ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Query Performance
Duration: 1m0.383519958s
Total Events: 944
Events/sec: 15.63
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 280 MB
Avg Latency: 421.75292ms
P90 Latency: 460.902551ms
P95 Latency: 491.340259ms
P99 Latency: 664.614262ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 538.014725ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Concurrent Query/Store
Duration: 1m0.291926697s
Total Events: 10479
Events/sec: 173.80
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 122 MB
Avg Latency: 18.049265ms
P90 Latency: 843.867µs
P95 Latency: 3.05038ms
P99 Latency: 404.540502ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 177.245211ms
----------------------------------------
Report saved to: /tmp/benchmark_relayer-basic_8/benchmark_report.txt
AsciiDoc report saved to: /tmp/benchmark_relayer-basic_8/benchmark_report.adoc
1758365287933287ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_relayer-basic_8: Lifetime L0 stalled for: 0s
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:536 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758365289807797ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_relayer-basic_8:
Level 0 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 0 B. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 64 MiB
Level 1 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 2 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 3 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 4 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 5 [B]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 6 [ ]: NumTables: 04. Size: 87 MiB of 87 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 4.0 MiB
Level Done
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:615 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758365289812921ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_relayer-basic_8: database closed /build/pkg/database/database.go:134
RELAY_NAME: relayer-basic
RELAY_URL: ws://relayer-basic:7447
TEST_TIMESTAMP: 2025-09-20T10:48:10+00:00
BENCHMARK_CONFIG:
Events: 10000
Workers: 8
Duration: 60s

298
cmd/benchmark/reports/run_20250920_101521/strfry_results.txt Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,298 @@
Starting Nostr Relay Benchmark
Data Directory: /tmp/benchmark_strfry_8
Events: 10000, Workers: 8, Duration: 1m0s
1758365295110579ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_strfry_8: All 0 tables opened in 0s
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/levels.go:161 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758365295111085ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_strfry_8: Discard stats nextEmptySlot: 0
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/discard.go:55 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758365295111113ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_strfry_8: Set nextTxnTs to 0
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:358 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758365295111319ℹ️(*types.Uint32)(0xc000141a3c)({
value: (uint32) 1
})
/build/pkg/database/migrations.go:65
1758365295111354ℹ️migrating to version 1... /build/pkg/database/migrations.go:79
=== Starting test round 1/2 ===
RunPeakThroughputTest..
=== Peak Throughput Test ===
Events saved: 10000/10000 (100.0%)
Duration: 9.170212358s
Events/sec: 1090.49
Avg latency: 448.058µs
P90 latency: 597.558µs
P95 latency: 667.141µs
P99 latency: 920.784µs
Bottom 10% Avg latency: 729.464µs
RunBurstPatternTest..
=== Burst Pattern Test ===
Burst completed: 1000 events in 172.138862ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 168.99322ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 162.213786ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 161.027417ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 183.148824ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 178.152837ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 158.65623ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 186.7166ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 177.202878ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 182.780071ms
Burst test completed: 10000 events in 15.336760896s
Events/sec: 652.03
RunMixedReadWriteTest..
=== Mixed Read/Write Test ===
Pre-populating database for read tests...
Mixed test completed: 5000 writes, 5000 reads in 44.257468151s
Combined ops/sec: 225.95
RunQueryTest..
=== Query Test ===
Pre-populating database with 10000 events for query tests...
Query test completed: 3002 queries in 1m0.091429487s
Queries/sec: 49.96
Avg query latency: 131.632043ms
P95 query latency: 175.810416ms
P99 query latency: 228.52716ms
RunConcurrentQueryStoreTest..
=== Concurrent Query/Store Test ===
Pre-populating database with 5000 events for concurrent query/store test...
Concurrent test completed: 11308 operations (1308 queries, 10000 writes) in 1m0.111257202s
Operations/sec: 188.12
Avg latency: 16.193707ms
Avg query latency: 137.019852ms
Avg write latency: 389.647µs
P95 latency: 136.70132ms
P99 latency: 156.996779ms
Pausing 10s before next round...
=== Test round completed ===
=== Starting test round 2/2 ===
RunPeakThroughputTest..
=== Peak Throughput Test ===
Events saved: 10000/10000 (100.0%)
Duration: 9.102738s
Events/sec: 1098.57
Avg latency: 493.093µs
P90 latency: 605.684µs
P95 latency: 659.477µs
P99 latency: 826.344µs
Bottom 10% Avg latency: 1.097884ms
RunBurstPatternTest..
=== Burst Pattern Test ===
Burst completed: 1000 events in 178.755916ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 170.810722ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 166.730701ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 172.177576ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 164.907178ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 153.267727ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 157.855743ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 159.632496ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 160.802526ms
Burst completed: 1000 events in 178.513954ms
Burst test completed: 10000 events in 15.535933443s
Events/sec: 643.67
RunMixedReadWriteTest..
=== Mixed Read/Write Test ===
Pre-populating database for read tests...
Mixed test completed: 5000 writes, 4550 reads in 1m0.032080518s
Combined ops/sec: 159.08
RunQueryTest..
=== Query Test ===
Pre-populating database with 10000 events for query tests...
Query test completed: 913 queries in 1m0.248877091s
Queries/sec: 15.15
Avg query latency: 436.472206ms
P95 query latency: 493.12732ms
P99 query latency: 623.201275ms
RunConcurrentQueryStoreTest..
=== Concurrent Query/Store Test ===
Pre-populating database with 5000 events for concurrent query/store test...
Concurrent test completed: 10470 operations (470 queries, 10000 writes) in 1m0.293280495s
Operations/sec: 173.65
Avg latency: 18.084009ms
Avg query latency: 395.171481ms
Avg write latency: 360.898µs
P95 latency: 1.338148ms
P99 latency: 413.21015ms
=== Test round completed ===
================================================================================
BENCHMARK REPORT
================================================================================
Test: Peak Throughput
Duration: 9.170212358s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 1090.49
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 108 MB
Avg Latency: 448.058µs
P90 Latency: 597.558µs
P95 Latency: 667.141µs
P99 Latency: 920.784µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 729.464µs
----------------------------------------
Test: Burst Pattern
Duration: 15.336760896s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 652.03
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 123 MB
Avg Latency: 189.06µs
P90 Latency: 248.714µs
P95 Latency: 290.433µs
P99 Latency: 416.924µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 324.174µs
----------------------------------------
Test: Mixed Read/Write
Duration: 44.257468151s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 225.95
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 158 MB
Avg Latency: 8.745534ms
P90 Latency: 18.980294ms
P95 Latency: 20.822884ms
P99 Latency: 23.124918ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 21.006886ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Query Performance
Duration: 1m0.091429487s
Total Events: 3002
Events/sec: 49.96
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 191 MB
Avg Latency: 131.632043ms
P90 Latency: 152.618309ms
P95 Latency: 175.810416ms
P99 Latency: 228.52716ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 186.230874ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Concurrent Query/Store
Duration: 1m0.111257202s
Total Events: 11308
Events/sec: 188.12
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 146 MB
Avg Latency: 16.193707ms
P90 Latency: 122.204256ms
P95 Latency: 136.70132ms
P99 Latency: 156.996779ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 140.031139ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Peak Throughput
Duration: 9.102738s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 1098.57
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 1441 MB
Avg Latency: 493.093µs
P90 Latency: 605.684µs
P95 Latency: 659.477µs
P99 Latency: 826.344µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 1.097884ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Burst Pattern
Duration: 15.535933443s
Total Events: 10000
Events/sec: 643.67
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 130 MB
Avg Latency: 186.177µs
P90 Latency: 243.915µs
P95 Latency: 276.146µs
P99 Latency: 418.787µs
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 309.015µs
----------------------------------------
Test: Mixed Read/Write
Duration: 1m0.032080518s
Total Events: 9550
Events/sec: 159.08
Success Rate: 95.5%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 115 MB
Avg Latency: 16.401942ms
P90 Latency: 37.575878ms
P95 Latency: 40.323279ms
P99 Latency: 45.453669ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 41.331235ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Query Performance
Duration: 1m0.248877091s
Total Events: 913
Events/sec: 15.15
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 211 MB
Avg Latency: 436.472206ms
P90 Latency: 474.430346ms
P95 Latency: 493.12732ms
P99 Latency: 623.201275ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 523.084076ms
----------------------------------------
Test: Concurrent Query/Store
Duration: 1m0.293280495s
Total Events: 10470
Events/sec: 173.65
Success Rate: 100.0%
Concurrent Workers: 8
Memory Used: 171 MB
Avg Latency: 18.084009ms
P90 Latency: 624.339µs
P95 Latency: 1.338148ms
P99 Latency: 413.21015ms
Bottom 10% Avg Latency: 177.8924ms
----------------------------------------
Report saved to: /tmp/benchmark_strfry_8/benchmark_report.txt
AsciiDoc report saved to: /tmp/benchmark_strfry_8/benchmark_report.adoc
1758365779337138ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_strfry_8: Lifetime L0 stalled for: 0s
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:536 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758365780726692ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_strfry_8:
Level 0 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 0 B. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 64 MiB
Level 1 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 2 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 3 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 4 [ ]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 5 [B]: NumTables: 00. Size: 0 B of 10 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 2.0 MiB
Level 6 [ ]: NumTables: 04. Size: 87 MiB of 87 MiB. Score: 0.00->0.00 StaleData: 0 B Target FileSize: 4.0 MiB
Level Done
/go/pkg/mod/github.com/dgraph-io/badger/v4@v4.8.0/db.go:615 /build/pkg/database/logger.go:57
1758365780732292ℹ️/tmp/benchmark_strfry_8: database closed /build/pkg/database/database.go:134
RELAY_NAME: strfry
RELAY_URL: ws://strfry:8080
TEST_TIMESTAMP: 2025-09-20T10:56:20+00:00
BENCHMARK_CONFIG:
Events: 10000
Workers: 8
Duration: 60s